Skip to main content
Content Starts Here GSA Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) Database Skip to main content

Committee Detail

Note: An Annual Comprehensive Review, as required by §7 of the Federal Advisory Committee Act, is conducted each year on committee data entered for the previous fiscal year (referred to as the reporting year). The data for the reporting year is not considered verified until this review is complete and the data is moved to history for an agency/department. See the Data From Previous Years section at the bottom of this page for the committee’s historical, verified data.


HHS - 845 - Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council - Authorized by Law
Hide Section - GENERAL INFORMATION

GENERAL INFORMATION

Committee NameCenter for Scientific Review Advisory CouncilAgency NameDepartment of Health and Human Services
Fiscal Year2020Committee Number845
Original Establishment Date11/4/1988Committee StatusChartered
Actual Termination Date Committee URLhttps://public.csr.nih.gov/AboutCSR/Organizatio...
New Committee This FYNoPresidential Appointments*No
Terminated This FYNoMax Number of Members*13
Current Charter Date3/31/2019Designated Fed Officer Position Title*Deputy Director
Date Of Renewal Charter3/31/2021Designated Federal Officer Prefix
Projected Termination Date Designated Federal Officer First Name*Bruce
Exempt From Renewal*NoDesignated Federal Officer Middle Name
Specific Termination AuthorityDesignated Federal Officer Last Name*Reed
Establishment Authority*Authorized by LawDesignated Federal Officer SuffixPHD
Specific Establishment Authority*42 U.S.C. 282(b)(16)Designated Federal Officer Phone*(301) 435-1111
Effective Date Of Authority*11/4/1988Designated Federal Officer Fax*
Exempt From EO 13875 Discretionary CmteNot ApplicableDesignated Federal Officer Email*reedbr@mail.nih.gov
Committee Type*Continuing
Presidential*No
Committee Function*Scientific Technical Program Advisory Board
Hide Section - RECOMMENDATION/JUSTIFICATIONS

RECOMMENDATION/JUSTIFICATIONS

Agency Recommendation*Continue
Legislation to Terminate RequiredNot Applicable
Legislation StatusNot Applicable
How does cmte accomplish its purpose?*Section 492 of the PHS Act states that The Secretary...shall by regulation require appropriate technical and scientific peer review of applications in biomedical and behavioral research ... This committee is composed of 12 highly qualified scientific individuals with expertise relating to review procedures and policies for the evaluation of scientific and technical merit of applications for grants and awards. During the fiscal year, the Advisory Council met two times to discuss and advise the NIH in general on various topics related to the peer review process. These topics included, among others: (1) updates from the CSR Director; (2)
ENQUIRE: Evaluating Panel Quality in Review status updates; and (3) Review Criteria working group status update.
How is membership balanced?*The members of this committee are authorities knowledgeable in the fields of biological, medical, and behavioral research who have had experience with peer review. Members include experts such as physicians, basic and clinical investigators, and educators.
How frequent & relevant are cmte mtgs?*The Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council held two meetings during this reporting period. Nine working group meetings were also held on the following dates: 12/12/2019, 01/16/2020, 01/31/2020, 02/07/2020, 02/14/2020, 02/18/2020, 3/06/2020, 09/03/2020, and 09/18/2020.
Why advice can't be obtained elsewhere?*This committee is composed of recognized biomedical and behavioral research authorities and scientific and technical information systems experts who represent the forefront of research and technical knowledge. Their recommendations cannot be obtained from other sources because of their complex nature of research and of research program emphasis, and management requires a specialized balance and breadth of expertise not available on the NIH staff or from other established sources.
Why close or partially close meetings?N/A
Recommendation RemarksThe recommendations made by this Council were conveyed via a review of the meeting minutes and notes together with a CMO/Executive Secretary meeting.

This committee did not produce any reports during the fiscal year.

The Committee Decision Maker and Designated Federal Official roles are held by the same individual based on the assignment of responsibilities at the Center for Scientific Review.

Dr. Yasmin Hurd was reappointed to serve an additional year, 1/1/2020 to 12/31/2020. No new members were appointed in FY20.
Hide Section - PERFORMANCE MEASURES

PERFORMANCE MEASURES

Outcome Improvement To Health Or Safety*NoAction Reorganize Priorities*No
Outcome Trust In GovernmentYesAction Reallocate ResourcesNo
Outcome Major Policy ChangesYesAction Issued New RegulationsNo
Outcome Advance In Scientific ResearchNoAction Proposed LegislationNo
Outcome Effective Grant MakingNoAction Approved Grants Or Other PaymentsNo
Outcome Improved Service DeliveryYesAction OtherYes
Outcome Increased Customer SatisfactionNoAction CommentRevised and amended the structure of peer review committees managed by CSR staff. Updated review policies.
Outcome Implement Laws/Reg RequirementsNoGrants Review*No
Outcome OtherNoNumber Of Grants Reviewed0
Outcome CommentNANumber Of Grants Recommended0
Cost Savings*NoneDollar Value Of Grants Recommended$0.00
Cost Savings CommentThis committee is involved in providing advice on the peer review process and policies used in the evaluation of research grant applications.Grants Review CommentNA
Number Of Recommendations*74Access Contact Designated Fed. Officer*Yes
Number Of Recommendations CommentThe number of recommendations reflect those given by the renamed and restructured committee that was started March 2011.Access Agency WebsiteYes
% of Recs Fully Implemented*91.00%Access Committee WebsiteYes
% of Recs Fully Implemented CommentOne recommendation from FY 2018 that was previously reported as partially implemented has now been absorbed into a new FY 2020 project.Access GSA FACA WebsiteYes
% of Recs Partially Implemented*4.00%Access PublicationsNo
% of Recs Partially Implemented CommentOne new FY 2020 recommendation and two from previous years are in progress.Access OtherNo
Agency Feedback*YesAccess CommentN/A
Agency Feedback Comment*Oral and written reports are provided to members.Narrative Description*The goal of NIH research is to acquire new knowledge to help prevent, detect, diagnose, and treat disease and disability, from the rarest genetic disorder to the common cold. The NIH mission is to uncover new knowledge that will lead to better health for everyone. The Center for Scientific Review (CSR) is the portal for NIH grant applications and their review for scientific merit. CSR receives about 80,000 applications a year. The majority of those grant applications (70%) are reviewed by peer review committees managed by CSR. Since 1946, our mission has remained clear and timely: to see that NIH grant applications receive fair, independent, expert, and timely reviews -- free from inappropriate influences -- so NIH can fund the most promising research. NIH advisory councils provide a second level of peer review and make funding recommendations based on priorities set by Congress, DHHS, and the public. For over 60 years, this peer review system has enabled NIH to fund cutting-edge research that has allowed millions to leave their doctor’s office with new drugs and cures for diseases. This committee is responsible for providing CSR management with recommendations and advice on policy and practice pertaining to monitoring of and coordination of peer review activities at CSR.
Hide Section - COSTS

COSTS

Payments to Non-Federal Members*$11,800.00Est Payments to Non-Fed Members Next FY*$11,800.00
Payments to Federal Members*$1,309.00Est. Payments to Fed Members Next FY*$1,309.00
Payments to Federal Staff*$39,401.00Estimated Payments to Federal Staff*$40,426.00
Payments to Consultants*$4,400.00Est. Payments to Consultants Next FY*$4,400.00
Travel Reimb. For Non-Federal Members*$0.00Est Travel Reimb Non-Fed Members nextFY*$0.00
Travel Reimb. For Federal Members*$0.00Est Travel Reimb For Fed Members*$0.00
Travel Reimb. For Federal Staff*$0.00Est. Travel Reimb to Fed Staff Next FY*$0.00
Travel Reimb. For Consultants*$0.00Est Travel Reimb to Consultants Next FY*$0.00
Other Costs$0.00Est. Other Costs Next FY*$0.00
Total Costs$56,910.00Est. Total Next FY*$57,935.00
Federal Staff Support (FTE)*0.20Est. Fed Staff Support Next FY*0.20
Cost RemarksDue to the COVID-19 pandemic, FY2020 meetings held after March 12, 2020 were virtual only which reduced committee operating costs. If face-to-face meetings resume, committee costs for FY2021 may be higher. Daily salary costs have been estimated for the Ex Officio member of this committee. The dollar figure represents a portion of her annual salary. No funds have been transferred between the committee and the agency. No additional funds are paid to Federal employee due to membership on this committee.Est Cost Remarks
Hide Section - Interest Areas

Interest Areas

Category
Area
Medicine
Health and Health Research
Hide Section - MEMBERS,MEETINGS AND ADVISORY REPORTS

MEMBERS,MEETINGS AND ADVISORY REPORTS

To View all the members, meetings and advisory reports for this committee please click here
Hide Section - CHARTERS AND RELATED DOCS

CHARTERS AND RELATED DOCS

No Documents Found
Hide Section - DATA FROM PREVIOUS YEARS

DATA FROM PREVIOUS YEARS

Committee

Data from Previous Years

 
ActionCommittee System IDCommittee NameFiscal Year
 COM-036672Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2019
 COM-034887Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2018
 COM-001937Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2017
 COM-002607Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2016
 COM-004099Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2015
 COM-004710Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2014
 COM-006190Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2013
 COM-006577Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2012
 COM-008375Center for Scientific Review Advisory Council2011
 COM-008719National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2010
 COM-010283National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2009
 COM-010804National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2008
 COM-012098National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2007
 COM-012709National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2006
 COM-013997National Institutes of Health Peer Review Advisory Committee2005
 COM-014567Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee2004
 COM-016002Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee2003
 COM-016588Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee2002
 COM-017622Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee2001
 COM-018522Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee2000
 COM-019592Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee1999
 COM-020331Center for Scientific Review Advisory Committee1998
 COM-021705Division of Research Grants Advisory Committee1997